Foreclosure Project: Increasing Profits with the Recycled Building Materials Store

You may or may not have noticed that I’ve been typing articles a bit less frequently in recent weeks, and that is for good reason: I’m doing real work these days!

The foreclosure project is going extremely well so far, both when measured against the original schedule and budget, and when measured on the fun-o-meter. We’ve had a few interesting design inspirations that should make for a nicer interior and exterior feel than we originally anticipated, which may lead to a higher rental income than the original budget as well.

The work completed so far:

  • Tearing down a portion of a wall to create a more open feeling between the living room and kitchen
  • Using a car jack to lift up the floor framing and adjusting some old support columns in the crawlspace to straighten a crooked floor
  • Framing new doorways between the bathroom and each of the two bedrooms
  • Removing all of the old ice-damaged copper pipe plumbing and rebuilding a nicer system with PEX pipes
  • Removing the cast iron and lead drain plumbing and rebuilding with ABS pipes
  • Clearing out the old bathroom toilet, tub, sink, and floor, reinforcing the subfloor, and building a new concrete showerpan as part of a fancy new corner shower. And adding the associated plumbing for shower, toilet, and sink
  • Creating a new area for the laundry machines (which mostly means new supply and drain plumbing), since they were previously jammed into an awkward corner near a bedroom window)
  • Swapping out old cracked and painted plugs and switches for new ones throughout the house
  • Starting to build a new kitchen shelving/countertop unit
  • Adding a nice new front door

I’ve got a few interesting how-to articles in the works to document how some of these things were done, but I figured I should tell the renovation tale in chronological order, which starts with shopping for the materials needed to rebuild this run-down house.

When you do a home renovation project, the materials are a huge part of the cost – both to your wallet and to the Earth. A project like this requires windows, doors, plywood, studs, tiles, concrete, lighting and plumbing fixtures, and many other things.

The interesting thing about renovations, at least in the wealthy Boulder County area where I live, is that people are always doing them. Middle-income people buy 60-year-old  fixer-upper homes and build them into more comfortable and energy-efficient places to live. Upper-income people often buy higher-end homes and make major changes even when the houses are quite fancy to begin with. Meanwhile, commercial buildings are always being built, torn down, and remodeled by larger companies.

The result of all of this activity is a huge surplus of building materials. Extra tiles left over from someone who bought too much for his bathroom. Entire kitchen cabinet sets and high-quality windows and doors from the homes of rich people who grew tired of the current layout of their house and had it rebuilt. Even unused beams and industrial-grade components from office construction projects. And of course various fixtures and parts of every type.

These things end up either on Craigslist in the “materials” section, or in the recycled building materials store. There is one of these stores in Longmont where I live, and one in the neighboring town of Boulder, and my house-renovating partner and I decided to hit up both of them to see what we could salvage for our project. And it was quite a score, since in just one trip we acquired these items:

A beautiful heavy-duty solid wood front door (with 12 panes of glass in a grid formation) for $20 (roughly comparable to a $400 door at Home Depot)
A set of four double-pane 2ft x 3ft window sashes in new condition for $4 each (to be used in the garage) (value about $300)
About 80 square feet of tile for 50 cents per square foot (total $40, worth about $200 new)
An apparently unused and very nice toilet for $30 (new value about $140)

The total spending on this trip to the store was $106, for materials we actually needed, that would have otherwise cost $1040. A savings of over 900 bucks, just for embracing the idea of used rather than new materials, and knowing where to shop!*

The limitation when buying your materials second-hand, is that you have to adapt your project to fit the materials, rather than custom-ordering the materials to fit your project. But that is pretty much a core concept of the Mustachian Way, so it is good practice for life in general.

For example, the new front door was the standard 36″ wide.. but the old door was only 32″. This worked out well, because you really should have at least a 36″ door in a house anyway, in case a future resident needs to move in a large refrigerator or couch. It is also necessary to allow someone to roll a wheelchair through comfortably. So today I cut out the old door and part of the wall, and framed a new wider opening into the front of the house. It took quite a few hours of cutting, routing, nailing, and even occasional swearing, but it was VERY satisfying to hear my heavy new door click precisely into place, fully weatherstripped and insulated, as I locked up the place to go home this afternoon. And the whole house now looks better when viewed from the street!

Since the recycled building materials store runs on donated items, not everything there is suitable for use in a high-quality renovation. The windows and doors are surprisingly good, as are the tiles and toilets and some of the kitchen cabinets. But the appliances, lighting, and plumbing fixtures are usually things like green or almond-colored fridges and stoves or gaudy brass faucets. For these things, you simply move on to Craigslist materials.

Even after passing through these two steps, I still end up purchasing plenty of new things. Wood, nails, adhesives, shower valves, plumbing, and many other things are rarely available used.

But by getting some of the most expensive things from these alternative sources, you are really “focusing on the big wins**”, and shaving thousands off of any renovation project budget.



* Still think we’re going to have trouble with our profit margin, Joe? ;-)

**I  wonder if Ramit Sethi shops at the used building materials store?


  • Jeh November 15, 2011, 7:11 am

    Great advice, and timely too as I’ll be doing some of this stuff on my new home over the next year or two. Now if only I could pick up some used skillz at a good price…

    • MMM November 15, 2011, 9:18 am

      Didn’t I hear you mention at some point you live in Colorado? Stop by on a weekend for an edicational project workshop any time if you like! It would be fun to exchange helping labor for on-the-job learning.

      • Jeh November 16, 2011, 8:00 am

        Indeed I do live in CO, probably an hour and a half from Longmont. That’s a might generous offer you’ve made and one I’ll be sure to take you up on after the holiday craziness is over. Thanks MMM!

  • Brian M. November 15, 2011, 7:27 am

    So, did you haul all that material back on your bike?

    • MMM November 15, 2011, 8:00 am

      Haha.. Unfortunately this particular run was done in “La Mujer”, my construction minivan. But I have indeed set several hauling records with the bike trailer on other days of this project. One day at Lowe’s I actually saw two other bikes in the rack set up for hauling. MMM readers perhaps? ;-)

      • jaliscokid November 18, 2011, 1:04 am

        Naming your minivan “the woman”! Hope your wife doesn’t feel she’s in the same league. Ha.
        I did a bunch of rehab on a 100 year old house. One project in particular was cutting away an old laundry/mudroom floor of dryrot/termite damage. My cobbled together fix with a mix of new and recycled wood was pretty stout, but I don’t know if it’ll last ten years or thirty. Also I got lazy/cheap and used a variety of nails to pound in a plywood floor, on which I laid tile. Hopefully, the floor won’t start squeaking. Probably should’ve splurged on a box of screws.
        In the master bath we laid a bunch of nice marble and put in a nice commode and sink, but got cheap on the tub, spending less than a hundred at Home Depot instead of ordering a Kohler for 4-500. I wonder if the quality x years of service will be a point of regret. The cheap tub looks okay, but feels flimsy underfoot.
        My advice is to consider the cost or value of labor on such permanent installs and decide if getting the right thing the first time is a better decision.
        But you can’t beat doing it yourself!

        • MMM November 18, 2011, 9:20 am

          Yeah, I agree – I always stick to top-quality materials regardless of the source, because my goal is to only renovations that are considered nice for several decades.

          The Construction Minivan (La Mujer Azul) is named in honor of her predecessor, El Amarillo, which was a 1984 Nissan compact pickup truck that was my work truck for the previous 5 years (and is still alive to this day, I just finally returned it to the friend who lent it to me). When I upgraded it to this powerful van, people made fun of me for looking like a Soccer Mom instead of a contractor. So I named it La Mujer.

          El Amarillo was named in Spanish because my friend lived out of the back of it on a beach in Mexico for some time. Also, in Colorado the construction trade has a large percentage of Spanish-speaking people, so we honor this tradition by naming our construction-related tools in Spanish. “Donde estan los espaciadores del azulejos!?”

  • RubeRad November 15, 2011, 7:40 am

    And used materials are not just for buying. Surely you sold that used copper for big $$, right?

    • MMM November 15, 2011, 8:02 am

      Yes, all iron will be donated to the metal recycling company and the copper will either be sold, or made into a solar hot water collector for the roof of my house later on.

      • trongod53 February 3, 2014, 1:36 pm

        Where do you keep all the extra materials from your projects?

        • Mr. Money Mustache February 4, 2014, 12:10 pm

          In a very nice workshed I built in the back yard, also out of some of those very materials :-)

  • Questionable Goatee November 15, 2011, 8:35 am

    Hi MMM,

    I’ve been quietly reading your blog for about a month, and now I’m completely caught up. I absolutely love it. I made a few engineery comments before this point, but now that I’m not playing catchup, I thought I’d pick a more appropriate alias and start on my path towards becoming a regular heckler. Actually, I shouldn’t get your hopes up with that choice of wording – chances are I’ll mostly be asking questions and basking in all the glorious badassity. I’m at work (not the self-employed variety) and should get back to it, but count me in as one of your readers who’s especially interested in the renovation project. I just started my first out-of-school job this past June, and I currently rent, but buying a fixer-upper is increasingly in the back of my mind. If I were anywhere near you, I’d gladly come exchange sweat for knowledge, but that, sadly, is not the case.

    Keep it up, and I love the avatar. And know that part of the reason I biked to work today was your true cost of commuting article, which is the first post I read here, and the one that I share the most.

  • Chris November 15, 2011, 8:50 am


    Where/How did you acquire your carpentry/rehab skillz? I’ve would like to do some rehabbing myself at some point. Thanks!

    • MMM November 15, 2011, 9:16 am

      I just started doing things and learning from my own mistakes. Most of the best knowledge and experience was picked up since 2005 when I quit the real job.

      But I’d suggest the best thing to do for someone just starting out is pick a project to do on your own house, then get a few library books and watch a few YouTube videos on what you want to do. Feel free to ask me questions as well.

      I wrote a little bit on my own history in the trade in this older carpentry article: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2011/07/20/get-rich-with-carpentry-and-home-renovation/

  • qhartman November 15, 2011, 9:54 am

    Great stuff. I did a remodel in my laundry room recently and we used a bunch of used materials. For the counter I used an old 50’s era kitchen table top. You know the kind with the “boomerang” formica and the aluminum trim? It nicely matches the steel cabinets and counter we inherited from my wife’s grandmother from the same era. Found it for $20 at our local building supply recycler, cut it to width, mounted the laundry sink, and used galvanized pipe for legs on the front. I still need to figure out a good way to cut down the aluminum edge trim (so it is the same thickness as the table surface) on the section I cut off so I can use it as a backsplash. I’m afraid using a jigsaw will end up with a really messy cut, or end up pulling the trim out of the edge of the surface…

    • MMM November 15, 2011, 9:35 pm

      A table saw would cut that aluminum edge off cleanly if you have one. Then you could use a sander to smooth it off the rest of the way. Or the whole thing could be done with a grinder with a cutoff wheel installed as a slightly more A-team-style method.

    • Matt November 15, 2011, 9:41 pm

      saw-all? or a table saw but that would require taking it off … i think a saw-all would work

  • Chris November 15, 2011, 10:11 am

    You seem to have a little better luck than I have w/ the used materials store. I’ve stopped off at the Boulder ReSource a few times while in the area (dropping off recycling before we had curbside pick up), but it’s been about 7 years since I’ve been there. Back then, it was mostly beat-up and dated fixtures and appliances and dimensional lumber at a cost fairly close to new.

    It seems like times may have changed there (I think they moved to Arapahoe Rd to a larger location too), so maybe it’s worth revisiting this avenue… I have a constant stream of renovation projects going at my house.

    Interesting comment about the solar hot water heater too. I built a solar hot water heater / pressurized shower for my van this summer, so I could shower while on a 2+ week road trip to a trail running race. It worked well, but I need to redesign the collector element to maximize heat gain.

  • Tyler November 15, 2011, 12:18 pm

    This is an awesome article. I had no clue these existed. On my way there this weekend!


  • Nathan November 15, 2011, 12:36 pm

    We have a couple of those stores in Colorado Springs. One of the other nice things about them is that you can often find replacement parts for older house components (shutoff valve handles, etc), thus saving the trouble of replacing the whole component.

  • Brett November 15, 2011, 2:03 pm

    Great post. I’m not sure I’ve ever commented before, but felt the urge today after months of reading. This is pretty cool stuff, and really inspiring. Reading this blog has really helped me to pin down my own views on finance and plans for life. Thanks MMM.

  • et November 15, 2011, 2:17 pm

    Lucky you to live where things like this are available. At our local recycle stores everything is 1/2 step from the dump. Beautiful doors or windows would never make it there. A (minor) downside to living where people value older things and don’t give them away for free…

  • Paul Johnston November 15, 2011, 2:55 pm

    Great article :) I’ve seen how well this can work first hand – my Dad is an architect, and he has gotten a complete, as new kitchen (granite tops, cupboard, the lot) for a rental house, and an automated garage door and motor for our house, for free. Got both at building sites where houses where being renovated.

    • James November 16, 2011, 3:25 am

      Hey wait – I know this guy :-)

  • ph0rque November 15, 2011, 4:46 pm

    MMM, what is your advice on insulation? I’ve read about heat storage via heavy things, but I’m asking specifically about insulation.

    • MMM November 15, 2011, 9:18 pm

      Why, I love insulation, of course! The next post might be MMM’s guide to destroying your winter heating bill, which will be a good time to figure out some of the cost/reward numbers on various insulation projects, as well as other tricks.

      • Chris November 16, 2011, 10:27 am

        Great idea for a topic!

  • Questionable Goatee November 16, 2011, 8:37 am

    For those that are both interested in solar thermal energy and willing to do engineering style calculations, a great (text)book on the subject is Solar Engineering of Thermal Processes, by Duffie and Beckman. Buying it new is a bit pricey, and finding it used can’t be easy, but I’d like to think it’d be available at most college engineering libraries. If you really want to optimize a solar setup, this book is a great place to start, though it’s definitely not light reading. It touches on photovoltaics, too, since most of the optimization and design choices are extremely similar.

  • Bakari Kafele November 17, 2011, 3:22 pm

    Wonderful to know that this concept is nationwide.
    I remember reading an article about one a couple years ago, which the author seemed to think was a revolutionary concept, though we have had our Urban Ore operating profitably (while paying a living wage) since 1981.
    They have been the destination of more stuff I get in hauling runs than any where else, primarily because they accept just about everything, from toilets to clothes – even wood, nails, adhesives, shower valves, and plumbing – most of the receivers know me by name.
    It doesn’t hurt my decision to go there that (unlike Goodwill or other reuse options) they pay for dropping stuff if it is valuable enough.

  • Berta November 17, 2011, 5:44 pm

    Great article. We’ll have to look for a recycled supply store in our area. We have 5 acres so always have some sort of project going on

  • Nick January 18, 2014, 11:55 pm

    I see that this is a few years old now, but just coming across this post and MMM now. For anyone looking for a recycled building materials store in their area, check out the Habitat for Humanity ReStore. With more than 800 stores in the US, there may be one in your area. BONUS: All store proceeds go towards furthering Habitat for Humanity’s work. http://www.habitat.org/env/restores.aspx

  • Leerob March 11, 2014, 12:45 pm

    Hi MMM – your blog has truly helped me (and my hubby) be on the same page with our financial goals. Thank you for your blog!

    We are thinking of renovating our kitchen with just minimal help if at all – but we want to take out a wall that divides the kitchen and dining – what is the most cost efficient way to find out if the wall is weight bearing ?

    More power to you!

    • Michael December 23, 2015, 5:26 pm

      I imagine you’ve figured it out by now, but it’s based on which way the ceiling joists travel. Walls parallel to the joists are not weight bearing. Those perpendicular normally are, especially toward the center of the house (ie, the ceiling joists span from the outer walls to an inside wall/beam). If there is no story above your kitchen (ie, it’s an attic), there might not be any interior load bearing walls if the roof was constructed with trusses.

  • David March 28, 2015, 8:37 pm

    It would be nice to have one of those stores near me. Working in the home repair and remodeling business I was able to get much of the materials for building my own house for free. Actually it was better than free. I was paid to remove them from their original locations and haul them away. I got all my entry doors, kitchen and bathroom cabinets, some interior doors, windows and plumbing fixtures. My best freebie was a two car garage. I jacked it up and prepped it for the move, then I paid to have it moved 3/4 of a mile and placed on a new slab with radiant heat. If you know the contractors who work on expensive homes you can often get the materials as they are removed. Most of the wood for my house came from a very mustachian source, my own woodlot. I logged it, bought a used bandsaw mill and cut my own lumber. Some of that lumber became a solar heated kiln which was used to dry what went into the house. After I was done I sold the sawmill for $1,800 more than I paid.

  • MMM/Minimalist in Training October 13, 2017, 8:36 am

    Home rehab has been one of my goals since buying my first property… but so far I’m showing a complete lack of construction sense/skills. I’m not sure how, but even after measuring three times, cutting once, all of my laminate flooring came out too long or too short. I won’t even go into the poor baseboards. Is there a better (less costly) way of learning?!?

    • Slim October 13, 2017, 11:08 am

      Nothing beats in person real world experience, but Youtube can be your friend. For example: https://youtu.be/ZkvO99lswZg

      You’ll still be better off if you can get real world experience, and helping others out with their projects is a great way to do so. Maybe you have folks in your community that you could organize a regular “Meitheal” with? (Meitheal = Cool Gaelic word referring to a revolving communal work day https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communal_work#Ireland). Here’s another Youtube example of a meitheal at work https://youtu.be/EyUaTMqzoDs though you could possibly get more out of a less formal arrangement such as just helping one person with one project over several days.


Leave a Reply

To keep things non-promotional, please use a real name or nickname
(not Blogger @ My Blog Name)

The most useful comments are those written with the goal of learning from or helping out other readers – after reading the whole article and all the earlier comments. Complaints and insults generally won’t make the cut here, but by all means write them on your own blog!


welcome new readers

Take a look around. If you think you are hardcore enough to handle Maximum Mustache, feel free to start at the first article and read your way up to the present using the links at the bottom of each article.

For more casual sampling, have a look at this complete list of all posts since the beginning of time or download the mobile app. Go ahead and click on any titles that intrigue you, and I hope to see you around here more often.

Love, Mr. Money Mustache

latest tweets