135 comments

Frugal vs. Cheap

In the great transition from Clueless Consumer to Mustachian, a person must first overcome a significant obstacle: the perception that Frugal, Cheap, Tightwad and various other concepts mean the same thing, and that they are all nasty conditions that we should try to avoid.

So I’ve been meaning to lay down the law on this issue for some time. If you’ve read “Frugality is the New Fanciness“, you know that being frugal just means displaying some skill and good judgement in the way you spend your money – and thus it is a mark of status far greater than conspicuous consumption. Only about 1/20,000th of the US population has read that particular article so far, but once they do, our country’s desire to show off by making unnecessary purchases will be cured. No problem.

But that still leaves the issue of cheapness to be dealt with. What about Ebenezer Scrooge? What about the new reality TV series that a reader forwarded to me called “Extreme Cheapskates“?

Since you’re probably too busy to watch the actual video, I’ll give you the executive summary: In the linked episode, an unfortunate-looking man with really bad hair is profiled in his various money-saving adventures around town: scraping food off of the plates of other restaurant diners, asking for extra ketchup packets so he can refill his ketchup containers at home, and washing and reusing paper napkins, which he leaves hanging all over his kitchen.

Peppered throughout the show are voice-overs like “Roy estimates that over the last ten years, he has saved nearly $2000 by reusing paper towels”*.

Now, I’m not one of the standard douchebag consumers who derides any attempt to save money as pathetic. I’ve read plenty of misguided shit that internet commenters have made about my own lifestyle, and it is clear that the complainers do not get it. So I suspect that Roy is actually having a pretty good time with his little tricks, and whether his math is right or not, he’s doing pretty well overall. But I would guess that anyone who follows his lead might suffer severe social stigma for being “cheap”, and for many of us that is not an acceptable outcome.

Being cheap works perfectly well for many people. If you’re older, safely protected from the dating world from within the confines of a long-term relationship, and employed in a field where the cheapness doesn’t hold you back, you’re set. As your age and status grows, you naturally give less of a shit about any irrational preferences of younger society.

But I’ve made the entire journey from teenager to greybeard with a strong appreciation for the value of money, but an even stronger desire to be part of society, to have friends, girlfriends, fancy jobs, and some social status. For better or for worse, I like being part of a social scene, and while I have no problem with being unusual, I try not to let the unusualness get in the way of the lifestyle goals.

Imagine a high-school or university student who is in a rich city and looking for love. In this situation, squeezing out ketchup packets, wearing stained green 1980s sweatpants from a thrift shop, or refusing to go out on the town with friends can seriously cramp your chances of success.

Or perhaps you’re a young professional worker in the financial industry. If your boss and coworkers wear crisply ironed blue shirts and suit jackets around the 54th floor office, while you insist on Metallica t-shirts and Wal-mart jeans, your cheapness is not helping you get ahead.

Even in married life, canvassing the tables of the other restaurant diners to ask if you can take home their leftovers, while your wife covers her eyes in shame, may be an exercise in penny-wise and pound-foolish behavior.

But yet, the student who walks to campus instead of driving, or the finance professional who foregoes an expensive wine-collecting hobby, or the married Mustachian who lifts weights in his basement instead of joining the $200/month health club downtown can get away with his frugality just fine.

What makes the difference between frugal and cheap? Mr. Money Mustache has some guidelines to help you walk the fine line.

It’s (almost) all in your Mind:

Many of the worst spending addicts are buying things because of purely imaginary fantasies about the social status they will get. A specific brand of $400 purse or a Mercedes GL550. At this level, they are well beyond the lower threshold of what is required to fit in socially, and may even be popping out of the other end of normalcy, where people will wonder why the hell they buy such expensive stuff. I know several CEOs of multimillion dollar companies who are perfectly content to be seen in a Honda CR-V, and plenty of fashionable Los-Angelesy people who do not follow fashion brands at all. The key is that these people still understand social norms, but they are confident about not needing to stand out at the high end of them. And that confidence earns far more respect than expensive products can ever attract.

Frugal does not mean Owning Mostly Crap:

A cheap person may live for decades with the sorriest old fridge he could find on Craigslist. A frugal person might have a relatively new, and even nice looking, fridge, and yet spend less money owning and operating it. Similarly, the frugal person might own a more expensive bike or pair of shoes. The key to this counter-intuitive trick is to factor in things like energy consumption, longevity, time saved by owning a more effective product, and even life satisfaction derived from having a few very good things that you use every day. Frugal people still get to own and enjoy top-quality assets, tools, and investments.

Don’t spend on yourself, but don’t be afraid to spend on others: 

When you’re on a first date or out with friends, it may be perfectly appropriate to pick up the tab, spontaneously buy pitchers of beer, and otherwise burn off a week’s worth of grocery money in four hours. And do it without worrying a bit, because you know you can afford it in the long run. If you do it right, you’re buying experiences you’ll remember for a lifetime and building friendships of similar longevity.

The key is in what you do between these lifetime experiences. If you attempt to re-create them in the same way every weekend, you’re just building your career as an alcoholic. It you also pamper yourself with iPads, massages, and salon haircuts on the off days, you’re just creating a person who needs Pampers. So you can selectively spend to capture those fleeting Good Times… but live more like a spartan warrior when nobody’s around.

Make fun of Yourself, but don’t Embarrass Others:

On a typical day, I can be seen biking around town in a paint-splattered lumberjack shirt, patched jeans, and work boots, pulling a bike trailer full of groceries and/or power tools. To me, it feels more showy than a Mercedes, because I’m out riding in the sun while everyone else works. But the Mercedes drivers passing me may think I’m an unemployed hooligan. Occasionally, I’ll show up at the school to meet my son in this condition, and I find the other parents are dressed in their office worker or doctor or teacher clothing. Nobody seems to care at all, and I get a huge running hug from the boy when I arrive.

On the other hand, if I had a teenage daughter giving the valedictorian speech at the high school, I might not show up in my painting clothes. And at a restaurant, I never ask strangers for their leftovers, no matter how yummy they might look. It’s because these actions would embarrass others, and so my frugality would be inflicting pain on others even if I enjoyed it myself. It would become cheapness.

Use Social Responsibility as a Guide:

If you forego German SUV ownership, you’re not hurting society. In fact, you’re probably helping by eliminating a bunch of mining and fossil-fuel burning. On the other hand, if you dump your trash in the forest to avoid paying the city’s garbage fees, or haggle endlessly with the manager at the big-box store to get things for free, you’re not helping anyone but yourself.  Canceling TV service and taking up the more productive hobby of reading library books is Frugal. Saving the same amount of money by voting down property tax funding for your local school system is Cheap.

Physical fitness is a nice Substitute for style:

As a close companion to the first point about mental conditioning, comes the issue of your physical form. If you’re already so confident about yourself that you don’t care what the outside world thinks, good for you – you can skip this step. But for the rest of us who could benefit from a reassuring ally in life, solid physical fitness is a nice one.

Although it is a form of discrimination, fit people are considered more attractive in our culture, and attractive people get hugely unfair benefits in all areas of life. Dating, business hiring and promotion, and even presidential elections are strongly influenced not just by how competent people are, but also on the purely physical impression they make. You can totally game this system just by giving yourself a generally athletic form. The boost in self-confidence combined with the actual change in how other people view you can create a virtuous circle. You will earn more money, even as you can confidently get away with more Frugal tricks without taking shit from your friends and coworkers. And all this shallow appearance stuff is of course just the icing on the cake of living a longer and more energetic life in general!

Artsy-ness Makes Cheap Stuff Cool:

My mom is an artist and my younger brother is an indie rock musician. They’re creative and eccentric and great, but they don’t make a lot of money with that talent. So both of them have scraped by for many years on incomes that most people would consider inadequate. But when you visit them, there is not a sense of cheap deprivation in their homes… instead there is just really interesting coolness. Bizarre found objects get adopted and shaped into stylish pieces of artwork, unsightly nooks in an old brick wall get painted and become chic shelves you wish you had at home, and scribbly drawings and tour posters somehow work just right for the audience. I’ve seen my brother, wearing old thrift store discards and 1980s pinstriped suit pants, rock a packed venue of hipsters until tears streamed from their eyes. The lesson is that artistic expression is an excellent substitute for using money to be appreciated.

Choose Wise Friends, not Vacuous Consumer Drones:

Although these tips are designed to keep you on the good side of society as a whole, you can also fine-tune the crowd with whom you choose to hang. There are still some circles of people caught up hopelessly in consumer lifestyles – those who jet out for trips to the shopping mall between episodes of reality TV shows. But luckily, there are plenty of people who are not like this, and they want to be your friends too. The battle to maintain a better lifestyle will be much easier if you pick the right crowd.

So let’s draw a line between frugal and cheap. You can be as badass as you want about frugality, and yet you can still shed society’s scornful comments about what it means to be cheap, all while being confident that you are doing the Right Thing.

 

 

 

*which sounds like bad math to me. Would you really spend almost $200/year on paper towels? I probably spend less than $10.00, and that includes a few bucks for washing and replacing luxurious dish towels and cloth napkins as needed.

  • John S December 2, 2012, 11:18 am

    I like to quantify purchases by how many times I can go to bars or on dates. Thinking about the opportunity cost of something is a great way to make frugal, but not cheap choices for me.

    Do I want an Ipad or to go to out and be social 10 or 15 times? The answer is almost always be social.

    Reply
  • JB May 20, 2014, 10:54 am

    I have dress shirts I bought over 10 years ago, They are still fine. Don’t buy clothes at Target if you want them to last more than a couple of years. Sometimes quality is worth the price.

    Reply
  • Burak June 18, 2014, 3:00 am

    Excellent piece of work MMM! Thanks and congratulations! This distinction has to be made clear enough, which you succeeded in this piece of art, especially in the part which you titled “Don’t spend on yourself, but don’t be afraid to spend on others”. I loved it :)

    Here is what I learned in my life (especially in recent years) about frugality:

    There is a great difference between frugality and stinginess/cheapness. Just as humility is a praiseworthy quality superficially resembling but different to the bad quality of servility, and dignity is a laudable virtue superficially similar to but different from the bad quality of haughtiness, so too frugality bears a relation to stinginess (and cheapness), which is a mixture of baseness, avarice, miserliness, and greed. There is merely superficial resemblance.

    Since I like stories and story-telling, and since story-telling is awesome, here is a cool one from very old times:

    Being one of the most distinguished and learned of the people of his time, a man named Abdullah, one day while shopping in the market, in order to be economical and to preserve the confidence and integrity on which trade depends, he disputed hotly over something worth a few chips. Someone saw him, and imagining this famous noble person wrangling over a few chips to be an extraordinary stinginess, he followed him in order to understand his conduct. Next he saw that Abdullah was entering his house and had spotted a poor man at the door. He chatted with him for a bit, and the man left. Then he came out of the second door of the house and saw another poor man. He chatted with him for a while too, and the man left. The person, who was watching from the distance, was curious. He went and asked the poor men: “Abdullah paused a while with you. What did he do?” Each of them replied: “He gave me a gold piece.” “Glory be to God!,” exclaimed the man, and thought to himself’: “How is it that he wrangled like that over a few chips in the market, then was completely happy to give away two hundred chips in his house without letting anyone know?”

    He went to Abdullah and said: “Solve this difficulty for me! In the market you did that, while in your house you did this.” Abdullah replied to him saying: “In the market it was not stinginess, but conduct arising from frugality; it was perfectly reasonable, and to preserve confidence and honesty, which are the basis and spirit of commerce. And the conduct in my house arose from the heart’s compassion and the spirit’s maturity. Neither was the first stinginess, nor the second immoderateness.”

    Alluding to this, a renowned scholar said: “There can be no excess in good, just as there is no good in excess.” That is to say, just as in good works and benevolence there can be no excess or wastefulness-so long as they are for the deserving, so too there is no good at all in wastefulness and immoderateness.

    Reply
  • Theora June 23, 2014, 3:49 pm

    Instead of re-using paper towels, I use dishtowels and wash them frequently, same with napkins. Cloth napkins are much nicer to use, and it takes little time to fold them after laundering. Actually, I do re-use some of my paper towels to wipe up grease. I’m on a septic system, and grease is bad for it. The greasy paper towels go in the woodstove; they’re great for stating a fire. I don’t mind being kind of cheap. I get great clothes at thrift stores and am able to change my wardrobe often. The US has a huge oversupply of consumer goods; I don’t need most of that stuff, and I prefer opting out of consumerism. I agree about buying quality for some things, like shoes, or a car. I buy good cars, just not new. I know when my car needs to be replaced, so I can take my time shopping, and usually get a good deal. By staying out of debt and having savings, I can buy what I need when there’s a good deal.

    The only regret I have is missing concerts and other events when I was younger and didn’t want to spend. So, spend on meaningful experiences, if you can do within your budget.

    And be generous with the charity(s) of your choice.

    Reply
  • Steve August 5, 2014, 4:44 pm

    The story of the man who washes paper towels to save money is entirely rediculous. The issue is that nowadays it costs hundreds of dollars a month just to get a place to live. This dwarfs all other costs. The cost of housing is so high that he could probably burn an entire roll of paper towels every day and not notice. That’s the reason poor people today are are called “the homeless”. Historically food and clothing was expensive and housing was cheap. The green revolution and the industrial revolution, respectively, changed that around. Greatly increased population, zoning laws, and housing standards further increased housing prices. Thus, the number one way to live frugally is to get your housing costs under control. After that, there’s food, medical, and luxuries.

    I live on a few dollars a month. But I do it for real, unlike some made-for TV caricature. Yes, I’m homeless and I do a lot of dumpster diving, and I have no social life. But I don’t do silly, stupid, or anti-social things (like stealing catsup packets). I’m thin and get plenty of exercise. Contrary to what was written here, being in good physical shape will NOT attract females. Ever. YMMV.

    Reply
  • Kristin October 18, 2014, 9:58 pm

    A theme song for this post: http://www.jukebo.com/chris-connor/music-clip,miser-s-serenade-1955,xs38fq.html
    The Miser’s Serenade… I’m still trying to find the right balance myself.

    Reply
  • Marlon Duque May 2, 2015, 12:51 pm

    Friends of mine sometime criticize the way I live. I´ve been grown up with a frugal mother, and I consider myself as a frugal man. I respect the way others people live (sometimes I do not understand), but I do not criticize them. And when my friends insist that I’m cheap, I argue that I’m not and show my arguments (some of them showed in this article), and this arguing sometimes get me frustrated and tired. This article brings everything I believe in and wish some of my friends understood about being frugal.

    Thanks Mr. Money Mustache

    Reply
  • Erica November 28, 2016, 9:18 pm

    It’s funny, my Partner is really cheap when it comes to himself. I think I have mentioned previously the holey sheets when we moved in together…or the pair of dress pants he has had since his high school internship.

    A few months into our relationship was Valentine’s Day, which he used the work week to leave small gifts each day. I got all the generic thinfs, candies, flowers (calla lilies – my favorite!) and he ended the week at the nicest restaurant I’ve ever been too with the best champagne I’ve ever had. It was an over the top indulgence, but he could afford it because it was a special one time thing. It was also pretty obvious to me then that he was very much in love.

    Reply
  • Kevin April 9, 2017, 1:50 pm

    i totally agree with your definitions here. “you be you” has it’s limits, cause at a certain point if nobody wants to spend time around you you’re going to wind up a very unhappy camper. who we are is a process of negotiation between ourselves and other people whether we like it or not.

    Reply
  • Curtis February 4, 2018, 7:42 pm

    I think you are short selling thrift shops. You can find nice lightly used clothes at some of them. At our local store, we have picked up Levis for $8-$15, a brand new “Life is Good“ t shirt with the tag still on for $6, regular t shirts for $.08-$1.50, and in style suits in great shape for $15. Buying new clothes at ridiculous prices just seems like a colossal waste of money to me when people discard perfectly good clothing.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

To keep things non-promotional, please use a real name or nickname
(not Blogger @ My Blog Name)

The most useful comments are those written with the goal of learning from or helping out other readers – after reading the whole article and all the earlier comments. Complaints and insults generally won’t make the cut here, but by all means write them on your own blog!

connect

welcome new readers

Take a look around. If you think you are hardcore enough to handle Maximum Mustache, feel free to start at the first article and read your way up to the present using the links at the bottom of each article.

For more casual sampling, have a look at this complete list of all posts since the beginning of time or download the mobile app. Go ahead and click on any titles that intrigue you, and I hope to see you around here more often.

Love, Mr. Money Mustache

latest tweets