In my opinion, the first rule of being a reasonable person is admitting when you are wrong, so you can learn from it. So I want to admit something right now: I was wrong about spending money.
Remember how all this time I’ve been telling you that life is better if you aren’t focused on the pursuit of luxury? Yeah, well that turned out to be bullshit.
It was just a way of me trying to fool myself into believing I could be happy spending less money. Because I didn’t really have any other option at the time. Now that the money has started rolling in, I realize that the other rich people weren’t so dumb after all.
See, without really planning or deserving it, I stumbled into a goldmine by starting this website. It has become a truly once-in-a-hundred-lifetimes situation, with over 18 million people stopping by so far and hundreds crawling around at any given moment. With this level of traffic, even the minimal level of advertising you see at the bottom is enough to make freight trains of cash. More than enough money every month, for a family to live extremely well on for a year.
The pressure of all this money gradually overwhelmed me. It started with just tossing a $7.00 chunk of imported Gouda cheese into the shopping cart every now and then. I started throwing in a 12-pack of craft beer even when they were priced at 18 bucks, and sharing them freely with friends on the back patio. Then I bought my brother’s family a nice new fridge, because it was his birthday and they really needed one to complement their excellent cooking skills. I didn’t even notice the loss of that $1500 for a second. It makes me feel good every time I visit and see them putting it to good use.
So this made me realize, hey, even leasing a top-of-the-line Tesla Model S P90D at $1400/month would be just an imperceptible nibble out this incredible torrent of money. And I like fast cars. Especially when they are built on revolutionary technology that will change the world as we know it. It seemed worthwhile to at least try owning one to see if it would actually make my life happier. And it did.
Mrs. Money Mustache was not a car person at all, until she set the vehicle to “Ludicrous mode” and hit 60 MPH in 2.8 seconds. Now we have his and her Teslas.
I had been living in a 1532 square foot house with no garage, constantly moving things out of the way so I could get to other things. The place was too small. Why live this way? I could afford a bigger house. In Cash. Every year!
So we bought one – a nice 8200 square foot place just a couple miles away. You can still get a lot of house here in Longmont for $1.8 million, and with the interest rates so low, the mortgage payment on this place is only $8,500 per month. That’s a lot of money for a normal person, but again, at this new higher level it amounts to a few hours of work. Why the hell not?
Now the three of us finally have room to stretch out. To host family and friends in style. To do our own stuff without getting in each other’s hair.
I think I have finally absorbed the message of the many successful people that have stopped by to educate me in the comments sections of every newspaper I’ve had the good fortune of interviewing with over the years: My money is my own. I earned it, I deserve it, and it’s nobody’s business how I spend it.
After just a few more changes including some help with the house cleaning and gardens, private school for little MM, food delivery and better restaurants (turns out we don’t really like cooking after all), I found that our annual budget had swelled a little. We went from about $25,000 to $256,000.
Even after this adjustment, we’re still saving plenty, so where’s the problem? And we are much happier for the change.
Frugality is fine – I’ve still got plenty of tightwad cred with my programmable thermostat, a hole in my favorite sweater and duct tape patches on some of my winter gear. But no more of this extreme frugality like the old Mr. Money Mustache. That’s for poor people.
Oh, and April Fools, obviously.
The Real 2015 MMM Family Spending Report!
The part about the excessive income is real*. But I only mention it to show other wealthy people that we don’t live this slightly-less-ridiculous-than-average lifestyle because it’s all we can afford. We just live the best life we can dream up given our current level of skill, and this is what it happens to cost.
Our total 2015 Actual Spending was $23,941.44 according to the spreadsheet. While most humans that have ever lived since the invention of currency would find this to be an insanely high amount to work with, it can be a surprise to some of my fellow one-percenter Americans. So here are a few mental adjustments to keep in mind:
- We own our house with no mortgage. If you were to finance a place like this, the monthly payment would be at least $1700/month. So you’d add $20k if comparing to a mortgaged life.
- It doesn’t include income taxes. If you live at this level of spending and set your income level (from investments) to match it closely, you’ll pay no income tax. If you’re still earning and saving, you do need to pay the tax. In 2015, because of these unexpected earnings, I paid several times more in income tax than we spent on our entire lifestyle. But the amount of tax depends entirely on how much you earn, which is why I don’t count it as part of spending.
- This is only the spending, not the saving that any non-retired person should be doing. Even if you only max out an IRA, that’s another $5500. Hopefully much higher though : employer 401(k)s let you contribute $18,000 these days.
So all told, we consume at an equivalent rate to a fairly financially irresponsible family with an income of $62,000 per year. That is, if a family of three earned $62k, paid tax, foolishly took out a mortgage on a $400,000 house, and saved just a tiny bit into the 401(k), they’d run out of money at roughly this level of spending.
If they commuted to work in large cars like most people do, add another $15,000 or so. With just a few other nudges towards “normal” (cable TV or a taste for Starbucks or fancy shoes, for example) a lifestyle no more noticeably fancy than my own would consume an entire $100,000 salary very easily. So it’s not really an ultra-frugal life. Just a somewhat optimized version of an upper-middle-class life.
And here’s where it all went:
|Property Taxes||2,120||1411||We downsized houses in mid-2014. 2015 was the first full year of enjoying the new lower tax rate.|
|Food and Dining||7,109||7,400|
|Groceries||6,593||6,232||See article: Killing your $1000 Grocery Bill|
|Wine/Beer||322||627||This includes parties, I don't drink this much myself!|
|Restaurants, Coffee Shop||194||541||Our major indulgence increase this year. Longmont's "Flavor of India" and "Sushi Hana" are the chief beneficiaries of this spending.|
|Doctor Visits||484||0||A thankfully healthy year for all|
|Health Insurance||3,272||3,000||For 2016 this will be double due to a new health insurance plan. (A downside of the ACA for those with very high incomes)|
|Physical Therapy||435||Mrs. MM was recovering from a nagging case of "frozen shoulder" this year.|
|Auto and Transport||490||945|
|Gasoline||71||332||Includes two trips to Utah in my gas-guzzling van: one for the annual "Safety Pirates" snowboarding trip, one for camping with the family and some friends.|
|Insurance||347||357||Fantastically cheap thanks to Geico|
|Registration & Testing||72||169||2005 Scion xA and 1999 Honda Odyssey|
|Express Tolls||0||0||Started taking Uber to the airport instead of driving|
|Service & Parts||n/a||88||Wiper blades, brake shoes, and oil change supplies|
|Public Transportation||0||0||Nothing against the bus, Bikes are just faster|
|Utilities||1,614||1652||Electricity, Gas (heating, cooking), trash/recycling, city park fees, etc.|
|Cell Phone||300||539||Google Fi and Republic Wireless|
|Internet Access||360||692||Damn that is expensive.|
|Home Renovations||19||120||Curtains and some paint. Does not include $10k of materials used in actually finishing the build-out of this house, since we're still running a profit due to the 2014 downsizing.|
|Home Insurance||410||0||I am self-insured for now, since the cost (and extremely low probability) of replacing the house would not be a significant burden.|
|Landscaping/Plants||0||I did plant a remarkably successful tomato plant this year - probably got $100 of kickass tomatoes off of that thing.|
|Gifts/Donations||1,155||1,747||Mostly school/family gifts. Does not include donations made by the business.|
|Crossfit/Yoga||330||230||Mrs. MM switched to Yoga (social event with friends) and working out at home for this year.|
|School Tuition||0||0||Mixture of homeschooling and neighborhood public school|
|Shoes & Clothing||492||754||Both boy and lady got some fancy new winter gear this year.|
|Shopping Misc||654||1,274||Storage baskets, insoles, compost bin, terrarium, suitcases, computer stuff, bike parts, household items, microwave, ottomans, coffee grinder, axe, frying pan, cheese grater|
|Books, games, gifts||61||488||Includes several thousand Magic the Gathering Cards|
|Other||815||580||Monthly Netflix, Movies Out, Bike Parts|
|Travel||5,057||2,376||Flights to Canada in Summer, Estes Park VRBO house rental with inlaws in fall|
|TOTAL||25,330||23,941||Hey, looks like it actually went down this year.|
|Subtracting Tuition, Donations||24,175||22,194|
|Subtracting travel, crossfit||18,788||19,588|
|Subtracting organic/luxury food||16,442||17,531||Assuming a 33% increase on groceries due to organic + meat.|
|Subtracting home renovation expense||16,423||17,411||This is what our "no frills" living cost would be, unless we moved to a smaller house (Note: Misc category could be cut down a lot as well)|
And so it goes – the years turn by and our spending barely changes. Someday there will be more exciting surprises in this report, but for now life remains happy without becoming more expensive.
Ask Me Anything!
I usually don’t intrude too much in the comments section, but since there are a bunch of new people here these days I originally put up an open invitation here for any and all questions.
It was overwhelming but fun – I spent the entire April 1st furiously typing and clicking on the computer to answer questions. Maybe hundreds of them – I didn’t even keep track. All I know is that I have a very sore neck and a flabby midsection from spending almost the whole day indoors today. So I have to sign off – sorry I didn’t get time to answer all of them. Tomorrow calls for beautiful weather so I’m getting back out there.
You can read the results in the comments below. I hope some of it is useful to you!
How to track your spending: We do almost all spending using a good cash-back credit card, and let the Personal Capital and Mint apps automatically categorize everything and display it in pretty pie charts and percentages for us. As a non-budget person, I find this method of tracking to be revolutionary, as it happens even when you are busy living life and forgetting about money. If you prefer to work within the more disciplined framework of a budget, take a test drive of You Need a Budget. Used by a surprisingly large number of Mustachians, which is how I heard about it in the first place.
* So what will I do with so much extra cash? Why do I bother continuing to make any money if I don’t need it for myself? Many people ask this. The answer in my case is to continue to live roughly at this level of consumption, lead a secure and generous life, and reinvest the rest back into society, both through traditional charity and interesting projects made possible by the reach of this website (renewable energy, advocating bikes, making better cities, etc).
Thank you so much for sharing this every year! There’s no substitute for real life examples, and it has helped me prune the waste out of my own life.
What do you think about electric motorcycles like those offered by Zero. I know that despite sharing my love of motorized two-wheelers, you have shunned them due to the nonsensical cost-per-mile. The overall cost for my old sport touring bike was around 24c/mile (which assumes that my time to perform maintenance is free). By contrast my wife’s prius is somwhere around 22c/mile. Rough. Literally cheaper to operate the cage-machine.
However, doing the math on these wonderful new machines, the cost is somewhere around 11c/mile (assumes buying used of course). Due to the relatively high cost of bicycle tires (per mile), I estimate that these things are literally about the same cost to operate as a bicycle. The total cost of bicycling per mile I estimate to be around 7c/mile vs total of around 11c/mile for the motorcycle.
You can never understate the overall benefits of a bicycle, but a high-speed vehicle has it’s place occasionally. What do you think?